I am so excited to have a guest post today with Sarah Ockler! She has a really fun post today, in the spirit of love for all genres, which I totally adored and even though Contemporary is my favorite, I do read and love many other genres and I love this post talking about the common threads between all genres. Contemporary Realism vs. Paranormal & Fantasy: Smackdown or Lovefest?
----------------------
As an author of contemporary realistic teen fiction, I'm often asked about the imbalance in the bookstores between contemporary titles and paranormals -- yes, those sparkly black covers of awesome. Some have asked me why I write contemporary instead of chasing the fantasy "trend." Others want me to convince them to read one over the other, or defend my own favorites, or talk about why contemporary is so much better.
Some of this is in jest, of course. All in good fun. But sometimes it does feel like there's a bit of rivalry going on, doesn't it?
I'm not sure why. To me, fantasy isn't a "trend" anymore than realism *isn't*, and the only thing that's "so much better" is that teens and adults are reading tons of YA -- way more than we used to. A big part of that is availability and choice. Even as recently as ten years ago, bookstores might've only had one YA shelf, or the teen fiction might've been mixed in with the younger children's stuff. Now, it's so popular that it usually has it's own section, and that section includes rows of ever-expanding shelves -- plenty of room for magic *and* reality.
My favorite local indie, the Tattered Cover, just expanded its YA section, and they host young adult and middle grade authors almost every month -- contemporary, fantasy, scifi, dystopian, romance, mystery -- we're all represented, and we're all awesome. :-) Walking down those long shelves stuffed with sparkly black covers, pink ones, white ones, scenic ones, close up kissing ones, monster ones… it just makes me insanely happy to have so many choices for my ever-growing TBR list.
So what about the original question? Smackdown or lovefest?
I say lovefest. I love contemporary realism. I love fantasy, paranormal, and scifi. I love it all. Because in young adult fiction, contemporary realism and paranormal / fantasy are just two sides of the same coin. The difference is in the execution. Maybe your boyfriend broke up with you because the scent of your blood makes him want to tear you apart with his pointy little fangs. Or maybe he just likes another girl. Maybe your parents are getting divorced because Mom discovered that dad is a dark elf plotting to take over the world. Or maybe he just leaves the toilet seat up. These are silly examples, but the point is, the underlying emotional strife is the same. Both types of story explore complex emotions and issues like changing friendships, death, sexuality, sex, heartbreak, addiction, family problems, physical challenges, violence, and economic hardship, to name a few. Both feature multi-layered characters forced by difficult -- sometimes life-threatening -- external situations to dig deep to uncover their own hidden strengths. Both have the twists and turns and surprises that often come when teens experience new situations for the first time. And let's not overlook the best part -- all the kissing. Sexy vampires, beautiful witches, six-pack-ab-rockin' shapeshifters, and plain old regular humans… there's plenty of romance to swoon over in most young adult fiction. Team Kissing, are you with me? Yes!
So whether you're typically into contemporary realism or paranormal, whether you like your boys human or bloodsucking, whether you go gaga for girls with wings or wands or just plain old pom poms, whether you're reading about transgender issues or trans-species ones, whether you like escaping to the beaches of California or the halls of Hogwarts, I encourage you to read a bit more of… well… everything. This is a lovefest, after all. Let's show some love!
Need a few recommendations? Check out the newly posted Best Teen Books of 2011 over at Kirkus. Editor Vicky Smith says, "With shelves fairly groaning under the weight of paranormal love triangles, it may be easy to think that books for teens are all the same these days. Not so, we are delighted to report. In sifting through the piles of great books published for teens this year, I was happy to discover soulful romance of the utterly normal kind, deliciously frothy historical novels, piercingly intelligent nonfiction, thrillingly inventive fantasy and science fiction and some great kickass horror, as well as some books that may leave you weeping with laughter."
Some of my faves from the list are Misfit, Winter Town, Virtuosity, Anna Dressed in Blood, and Daughter of Smoke and Bone, and many more are on my TBR list. There's something for everyone over there. Happy reading!
~ Sarah Ockler
Author of Twenty Boy Summer, Fixing Delilah, and the upcoming Bittersweet (which features the special magic of cupcakes and hockey boys… mmmmm...)
Thank you again Sarah, so very much! I love it! :)
And for all my awesome readers, Sarah has been generous enough to donate a signed paperback of Fixing Delilah to one luck winner! This is a phenomenal book, absolutely amazing, and I'm already excited for whoever wins this one!
Enter Below. Like all Just Contemporary Giveaways, it will end Dec 10th. This is also only open to US/CN.









Wonderful post! I love all kinds as well. :) As long as there's romance. ;D Yay for Team Kissing! lol
ReplyDeleteBtw, I loved Twenty Boy Summer! <3 Haven't read Fixing Delilah yet, but it's definitely one I plan on reading.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree, I think there's room for all genres. Sometimes it's tough when people seem to think that all YA is paranormal or even that all paranormal are the same as Twilight. But thankfully there are also people who know this isn't true. I used to read contemporary books pretty much exclusively, but since getting into blogging more over the last year or so I've discovered some great paranormals and fantasy books that I probably never would have picked up before. I'm glad there are all kinds of different genres within YA, and I agree that usually there's a similar use of emotion in each novel, whether it has to do with an ancient curse or just dealing with high school.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Sarah - there's room for both. I think that when one sub-genre becomes especially popular (e.g. paranormal fantasy) it's easy to feel deluged. But the litmus test should always be: Is this a good book? As long as authors are feeling inspired to write great books, everyone wins.
ReplyDeleteOh, and Sarah's books are DEFINITELY great!
AWESOME interview! Love her! Haven't had the chance to read Fixing Delilah yet, but I loved Twenty Boy Summer.
ReplyDeleteI love this post because I read across the spectrum, too!
ReplyDeleteAshly F.
"Maybe your boyfriend broke up with you because the scent of your blood makes him want to tear you apart with his pointy little fangs. Or maybe he just likes another girl. Maybe your parents are getting divorced because Mom discovered that dad is a dark elf plotting to take over the world. Or maybe he just leaves the toilet seat up." ---> I LOVE THIS SO MUCH.
ReplyDeletefor someone who has struggled to want to read contemps, this little gem of a snippet of this guest post makes me smile!!
lovely thoughts, ladies! thank you!
Sarah's such a talented writer, I'm really looking forward to reading Fixing Delilah!!
ReplyDeleteAnd, I have to agree because like you said, I enjoy it all! Realism, paranormal, contemporary - the YA genre is perfect because it can include any or all of these terrific aspects in so many creative ways.
Thank you for the interview. I like the balance bwtween realistic elements and fantasy. It means I can connect with the characters but also let my imagination fly.
ReplyDeleteI agree! I read a little of everything, whatever my heart desires at the time. I wouldn't want to read the same genre over and over again, I like switching things up and keeping it fresh :)
ReplyDeleteI've never read any of Sarah's books, but I would love to start now. Thanks for the chance to win!
ReplyDeleteLoved Twenty Boy Summer! Can't wait for this one!! <3 Hope i win :)
ReplyDeleteGreat Guest Post! I'm so glad Sarah Ockler didn't bash paranormal for contemporary. She's right, there is room for both. The great thing is that there's so much to choose from!
ReplyDeleteShe mentioned one of my favorites Daughter of Smoke and Bone.
Heather
I'm glad we got straightened out about the new Antony John book. I'd love to read his new one. I'm going to join your contemps challenge though I'm leery of the Challenge2 part since I don't know what that entails. I read a lot of contemp.
ReplyDeleteHeather
Yes, a lovefest is definitely a better approach to this issue! I don't get why people really bother comparing the two genres and pitting them against each other. They're so very different in many ways and have different goals in mind, but there's no reason to say one is 'better' than the other. Live and let read! :D
ReplyDeleteAlso, Team Kissing FTW.
I don't know about anyone else but I find a balance of BOTH is best. After a heavy paranormal it's awesome to sink into a realistic world.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree. I prefer contemporary stories but I still like to throw in some fantasy/dystopian/etc. books in the mix. I think so long as books get teens reading, it doesn't matter what genre they are. :)
ReplyDeleteI agree, it is amazing to see so many YA books now and that they have their own section and it's full of a variety. I too love to walk through and look at all the pretty covers, from the fantasy, to the paranormal to the contemporary. I read them all and love to see them all. Great post!
ReplyDeleteAgree! I love them all and like to change up my genres :).
ReplyDeleteThis: "I encourage you to read a bit more of… well… everything."
ReplyDeleteI love contemporary, but I try to branch out and read a little of everything. It's refreshing to try new genres and you can certainly miss out on some great books if you limit your TBR pile to only one genre!
Thanks so much for this giveaway@! I love this book when read it last hear, and I would love to have the chance to win it. Sarah Ockler is one of my favorite authors. I can't wait to see what she's writing next!
ReplyDeleteSarah, you are so brilliant! You had me laughing so hard throughout this whole post. I like to think I fight with my sister because she takes after the ogre side of the family and I am more of a pixie. Just kidding....kind of! Your examples were hilarious and they are so right! I am a huge fan of both contemporary and fantasy. Both have made me cry, smile, laugh, and swoon on more than one occasion. And YES to Team Kissing <3
ReplyDelete-Katelyn
I definitely agree with this interview. I used to devour paranormal and fantasy books, but now I find myself gravitating toward contemporary novels. It's nice to have more variety in my TBR pile.
ReplyDeleteI think that a book is GREAT when the author stays true to themselves and their vision. A book will not be as good if an author is just trying to be or write something they are not. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteI'm new to the contemp genre and a lot of what you said resonates with me. I need to read more contemp!
ReplyDelete